The Most Dangerous Pitch

The Most Dangerous Pitch

The Most Dangerous Pitch

Victims of automobile accidents often report that at the moment of impact time seems to move in slow motion. I now understand what they experience. For one protracted fraction of a second time stood still. The din of the spectators faded to a distant thunder in my ears. My gloved hand crept skywards. It paused motionless in front of me at about nose-level. The dull white leather clad ball balanced precariously on the edge of the mitt’s webbing, frozen in space. One thought replayed in my mind over and over, like a stuck 45 RPM record: I’m not going to catch it.

And then someone hit fast forward.

The speeding projectile tipped off my glove and mercifully slowed slightly. It slammed into my face, catching the cheek bone and upper eye socket squarely with a brain jarring, sickening thud.

Blood dripped onto the hard, cracked, sun-dried earth, creating puddles of crimson mud. This was the first time I’d been hit and unable to complete a play. That’s what made me the maddest; that and the fact that we were winning. I was pitching a shutout into the fourth inning: no walks; a couple of strikeouts. The nine guys behind me were doing a great job of handling the ball. And our opponents, a team made up of tough, young Dominicans and Puerto Ricans, were no slouches in the field.

I was still standing when the first player reached me. I think it was Reyes from the other team. He’d been on second base. Bent over, my blood pooling at my feet, I felt the comforting touch of his strong hand on my back.

“Easy, take it easy.”

My hand cradled my swollen right eye. It felt as if it would pop from its socket. Adrenalin still surged in my body as my good eye desperately searched the infield around me. “Where’s the ball… where’s the damn ball?”

Someone hollered to stop play. “He’s hurt,” the ump shouted, “it’s a ground rule double.”

A double meant that Reyes would score. I cursed silently and then caught myself, asking for God’s forgiveness; and to save my sight. By now my eye throbbed, swollen shut, swelling to nearly the size of the softball that struck it.

“Damn,” I repeated out loud as my team mates began to crowd around. Shock and concern showed through their troubled cries of, “Oh, God,” and “Wow!” Head and face wounds do tend to bleed a lot. But then you’d have thought someone spilt a quart of red ink into the parched dirt.


As a pitcher, you have an invisible target painted on your chest. You are fair game for every line shot, bouncing drive, and screaming grounder that burns its way up the middle. On the mound you have two responsibilities: pitch the ball, and get set. Or, better put, catch the ball without getting killed in the process. In baseball, you are sixty feet, six inches away from the batter, and raised ten inches. Softball plants you on the same plain as the hitter, some forty-seven to fifty feet from home plate. And those extra feet can make all the difference, the difference between a hit and an out; between a bad bruise and a career ending injury.

Baseball rookie for the Cleveland Indians, Herb Score led the American League in strikeouts each of his first two seasons. In 1957, during a game against arch rival New York, Score was struck in the eye by a line drive off the bat of Yankee Gil McDouglas. His comeback lasted five frustrating seasons. But the one-time overpowering pitcher never again posted a winning record.

While waving to a relative during warm-ups at Washington’s Griffith Stadium, Julius ‘Moose’ Solters was struck in the face by a thrown ball. The veteran American League outfielder fought back from the injury, but it eventually caused him to go blind.

I was fearful of suffering the same fate.


No one intentionally tries to hit the pitcher. That would be stupid. Chances are you’d be thrown out at first; maybe out of the game if your intentions are known. It just happens, more often than many people realize. Hairline shin fractures, battered kneecaps and dislocated fingers are a part of a pitcher’s life. I should have known better. I have the experience, and the scars, to prove my point.

In slow-pitch softball, after release, there is an easy two-and-a-half to three seconds before the ball reaches the plate. There’s plenty of time for a hitter to adjust himself in the batter’s box, and more than enough time for the pitcher to get set. Freak accidents do happen. But there is no excuse for any player not to be ready.

Getting sloppy on the mound can shorten your career considerably. A combination of recent victories, plus having avoided being seriously hit for some time, conspired to make me careless. Instead of watching the path of the pitched ball, estimating the direction of the batted ball, and getting set, I found myself remaining planted on the rubber, no better than a spectator, after the pitch.

To compound matters, I’d been working on a new pitch. The past couple weeks, while honing my curveball, I discovered a sharp downward breaking ball. During batting practice, the new pitch proved devastating to right-handed hitters, and frustrating for lefties. Cutting sharply inside and dropping with a wild spin, no one seemed to be able to strike the ball squarely. The best efforts of some of the most skillful hitters resulted in a bouncing hard grounder or a low line drive. A few were able to get the ball in the air. When they did, it usually went straight up for a short pop fly.

Because of the propensity of even pull hitters to send the pitch back up the middle of the infield, I jokingly dubbed my new weapon my “Come Back Pitch.” During practice I threw out several surprised opponents at first base. My come back, often as not, came back right into my waiting glove.

I worked on perfecting my new pitch. Slow-pitch softball is far from an exact science. Tossing the oversized sphere at the proper height and arc, the balls fall victim to the slightest breeze. Sometimes you can make the wind work for you, bending an outside lob right into the face of an unsuspecting hitter, or cutting the edge of the plate. That is, if you are lucky. Otherwise, the best you can hope for is a corner plate strike. Knuckleballs, spinners and curveballs can also be used to thwart hitters but can be difficult to master. My “Come Back Pitch” pitch had the added advantage of a fast, tight spin, making it extra difficult to place squarely on the bat.


One of my heroes of the old-time players is a pitcher for the hapless Washington Senators, nicked named “the Big Train.” From around 1900 through the ‘20s, Walter Johnson terrorized hitters with what most consider to be the fastest fast ball in the major leagues, then and since.

How fast was Johnson’s fast ball?

Consider Ray Chapman.

Chapman once took first one, then a second blazing fast ball from the Big Train, Johnson. Stepping out of the batter’s box, the stunned hitter headed towards the dugout only to be reminded by the umpire he had another strike coming. Chapman continued on his way, calmly calling back over his shoulder, “Keep it. I don’t want it.”

Perhaps the ill-fated Chapman should have taken the event as an omen. On October 10, 1920, while up at bat, Ray Chapman was struck and killed by a fast ball from pitcher Carl Mays.


We jumped out to a quick two-run lead our first at bat. I managed to set down three of the four batters I faced in the bottom of the first, including a strikeout. Our team went three up, three down, as did the opposition, in an uneventful second inning. We went up four to nothing with two more runs scored in the third off of left fielder Ron’s triple. The last of the third started off innocently enough with a routine pop fly. Then the bottom fell out. A single up the middle, a misplayed grounder followed by a line shot, and the bases were loaded. And the top of their lineup was coming to bat.

It was time for some fancy arm work.

It was time to try out the “Come Back Pitch.”

The first pitch caught Alfredo, a good hitter, by surprise. Looking at first like it would fall short and outside, the ball veered sharply inside, slicing the edge of the plate. The look on his face was priceless.

Ok… strike one…

So far, so good...

I gave him two junk pitches to think about, then another Come Back. It tipped off the edge of his bat and rolled harmlessly towards the mound, right to me. A quick throw home for the force and there were two outs.

Franco wouldn’t be so easy. After a couple of called balls and a Come-Back called strike, I gave him a sharply curving breaking pitch, thanks to a friendly cross breeze. He swung hard. But the backspin sent the ball straight up. It was caught by the catcher. Out number three and we were out of the inning. The Come Back had done its job.

Our fourth inning produced a couple of hits but no runs. Then it was their turn again. And their three best sluggers were coming to bat.

Jimmy is a strong pull hitter. He had managed a double and a triple off of me in other games. He wouldn’t bite on a short lob which fell ineffectually in front of the plate. My second pitch, a Come Back, he sent past me to my right. Our shortstop bobbled the hard-hit bouncing grounder but managed to throw Jimmy out at first.

Next was Reyes, the team’s cleanup hitter and a threat to send one out anytime at bat. He’d gotten a deep dangerous fly off of me in the first inning which thankfully turned into a long out. I toyed with him best I could, giving him nothing to swing at until the count was three and two. Then he saw my Come Back. He not only saw it, but lined it like a rocket past me, the shortstop, and the infield for a double. My Come Back was earning its name. Those two shots should have told me something. They didn’t. I was still standing flatfoot on the rubber.

Bugara hits the ball probably as hard as humanly possible. His drives jump to the outfield before anyone has a chance to react. He once hit three tape-measure homers over center field in three consecutive at bats in one game. I didn’t have the time or the inclination to fool around with him. Not with Jose at second and only one out. Even a sacrifice fly to the outfield would result in a run scoring. I took a deep breath, let it out, and tossed a Come Back.

And it did…

As best I can figure, the ball came off his bat and tipped off my glove in about half a second. That works out to something like 75 or 80 miles per hour.

And there I stood.

I raised my glove, but not quickly enough, not far enough.


It’s never a good sign when your attending physician grimaces at your injury. The swelling and discoloration were severe. It made looking at the damages more painful than the actual experience. I was helped off the field, still holding the bloody wad of tissue someone provided against my eyebrow. It’s interesting and strange to note that I never experienced any major pain, especially considering the seriousness of the injury. At the time of the impact, I felt as if punched by a gloved boxer, more surprising than painful. A dull, achy throb and a feeling of pressure against the eyeball were the main discomforts. After tolerating an hour of ice, the gash just below my eyebrow was cleaned and stitched. A comprehensive exam commenced including x-rays and a lot of discomforting prodding and poking. The doc said keeping the badly swollen and bruised eye socket well iced may have helped saved my sight. I was released with an antibiotic and strict orders to keep my eye iced constantly for the next twenty-four hours. The entire orbit around my right eye remained extremely tender, swollen, sore and ugly for several weeks. Two days after the incident, an optimistic optometrist said he could find no permanent damage, thank God. But I wasn’t out of the woods yet. He told me it would be weeks, maybe more, before the long-term effects of such an injury could be determined.


In the 1960s, Tony Conigliaro was well on his way to a hall of fame career. Joining the Boston Red Sox in 1964, in just a few seasons, the twenty-two-year-old right fielder hit an amazing 104 home runs, running up 294 RBIs, with a .276 average.

On August 18, 1967, Tony C came to bat in the fifth inning against California Angels’ pitcher Jack Hamilton. A fast ball, estimated near 100 MPH, struck Conigliaro in the left cheek bone. The impact shattered his eye socket and permanently damaged his left eye.

Conigliaro was carried off the field on a stretcher. It wasn’t immediately known if he would survive the injury. Tony survived and returned to the Red Sox in 1969, moving to the Angels in 1971. After three disappointing seasons, it was evident the damage done on that August night in 1967 was too great, and he retired.

Tony C suffered a massive heart attack and stroke in 1982 which left him in a vegetative state. The one time Cooperstown bound slugger passed away shortly after his 45th birthday in 1990.


One month later. It was too soon. I knew it was too soon. The days were growing short, the air chilly. Softball would be ending. I wasn’t about to spend the winter wondering how it would feel; wondering if I would pitch again; if I could pitch again.

Outwardly, my eye was healing quickly. All that remained was some discoloration and a forming scar where the stitching of the ball cut me.

But that was on the outside.

The pressure on my eyeball subsided, returning from time to time. And my depth perception was affected, but nearly normal. At least that’s what I told myself. But I was starting to be bothered by sparks of light, flashes they are called, and they can be harbingers of more serious problems to come.

Still, I was determined; stubborn.

For the first time in my life, nervousness and doubt accompanied me to the mound. Doing my best to shake the feeling, I steeled up some counterfeit courage and took my warm-up pitches.

Not bad…

Not good either…

Then again, a four-week layoff will rust up anybody’s arm. Even without a batter to face, I found myself purposely avoiding the pitch that had nearly blinded me. It’s too soon I rationalized. Just stick with the basics.

It did little to easy my churning stomach.

The first hitter of the game dug into the batter’s box. A familiar, reassuring voice reached me from left field. It was my friend Ron. “Give ‘em the old “Come Back,” Billy!”

And so I did.

About the Author

BJ Neblett

BJ Neblett is the author of numerous short stories and books including the contemporary literary fiction novel Elysian Dreams, and his personal historical memoir Ice Cream Camelot. His latest contemporary sci-fi novel Planet Alt-Sete-Nine was a finalist for the prestigious Endeavor Award. After a long career as a popular on-air radio DJ, BJ settled into a successful writing career. He coined the term "New Millennialism" to describe his own writings and a new emerging genre he sees as, "Thrusting cutting edge technology, concepts and ideas into the very core of classic human situations." When not teaching writing courses at Seattle's famed Hugo House For Writers, BJ can be found signing his books at many of the numerous Sci-fi/Fantasy conventions; on the mound pitching softball or relaxing with his ever-growing collection of records and vintage guitars. 2020 will see the publication of Wouldn't It Be Funny If..., his collection of short stories and Planet Alt-Sete-Nine: Princess Haylee, the second book in the trilogy.

Read more work by BJ Neblett.